Captain Gus's Steak Shop Menu (Update 2025)

Captain Gus's Steak Shop, located in Lancaster, PA, is a nostalgic dive spot offering mouthwatering cheesesteaks, subs, and sandwiches. The menu includes options like the Steak Salad, Cheese Steak entrees, Roast Beef Subs, and Fish Subs. Customers praise the fresh food, friendly staff, and great service that create a welcoming atmosphere. The home-cut fries with skin-on are a standout, and the prices are reasonable. The owner, Nick, goes above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience, making customers feel valued and appreciated. While some may find the cheesesteaks not the absolute best, the overall charm of the place and the simple, freshly prepared menu make it a worthwhile visit. Step back in time at Captain Gus's for a taste of delicious nostalgia and friendly service.